Which is the correct centerpoint - Layout A or B

[myfs_145115]

Master Cecil,
Kindly advise which is the correct centerpoint - Layout A or Layout B?
In Layout A, I included the garden area which is within the perimeter wall of the house. WithLayout A, the centerpoint will be the bathtub area. Ifthis is the correct centerpoint, should I move the bathtub? Thehouse is stillbeing constructed.
Main door faceswest3.
I did not include thegarage to get the flying stars.MS 6, WS 1, BS8.
Thank you.

[Cecil Lee]

It is best to you split it into two files that of layout A and another for B. As currently, it cannot be shown.

Quote

On 11/4/2010 10:35:18 PM, Anonymous wrote:
Master Cecil,Kindly advise
which is the correct
centerpoint - Layout A
or Layout B?In Layout A,
I included the garden
area which is within the
perimeter wall of the house.
WithLayout A, the
centerpoint will be the
bathtub area. Ifthis is
the correct centerpoint,
should I move the bathtub?
Thehouse is
stillbeing
constructed.Main door
faceswest3.I
did not include
thegarage to get the
flying stars.MS 6, WS 1,
BS8.Thank you.

[myfs_145115]

Master Cecil,
Please see the revised attachments. By the way, there is no garage door since the house is within a compound. Thank you.

Quote

On 11/4/2010 10:36:20 PM, Anonymous wrote:
It is best to you split it into two
files that of layout A and another for
B. As currently, it cannot be shown.On
11/4/2010 10:35:18 PM, Anonymous wrote:
Master Cecil,Kindly advise
which
is the correct
centerpoint -
Layout A
or Layout B?In Layout A,
I included the garden
area
which is within the
perimeter wall
of the house.
WithLayout A,
the
centerpoint will be the
bathtub area. Ifthis is
the correct centerpoint,
should
I move the bathtub?
Thehouse
is
stillbeing
constructed.Main door
faceswest3.I
did not include
thegarage
to get the
flying stars.MS 6,
WS 1,
BS8.Thank you.

[Cecil Lee]

Since within the living area, there is an open courtyard = lanai

If academically speaking, this missing area should be considered against the courtyard.

Then based on the concept of center of gravity; layout A closely match this concept: where roughly the missing corner matches the additional space or the additional non living space or protusion area may be reduced slightly where the area of the lanai (courtyard) equals the other protrusion.

Currently i am only eyeballing it only.

Quote

On 11/5/2010 7:35:33 PM, Anonymous wrote:
Master Cecil,Please see the revised
attachments. By the way, there is no
garage door since the house is within a
compound. Thank you.On 11/4/2010
10:36:20 PM, Cecil Lee wrote: >It is
best to you split it into two >files
that of layout A and another for >B.
As currently, it cannot be shown.On
11/4/2010 10:35:18 PM, Anonymous
wrote: >>Master Cecil,Kindly
advise >which >is the correct
centerpoint ?- >Layout A
or Layout B?In Layout A,
?I included the garden
area >which is within the
perimeter wall >of the house.
With?Layout A, >the
centerpoint will be the
bathtub area. If?this is
the correct centerpoint,
should >I move the bathtub?
The?house >is
still?being
constructed.Main door
faces?west?3.?I
did not include
the?garage >to get the
flying stars.?MS 6, >WS 1,
BS8.Thank you.?

[Cecil Lee]

These are futher illustrations:-
1. Frankly, even between your layout a and b; the center-point is pretty close to each other. Only thing is that under layout plan a, it falls within the toilet area (long bath)
2. Under the so called: center-of-gravity method:
2.1. The usual suggestion is to copy a layout plan. Paste it on a cardboard and cut-out the outline of the interior "living" space. And balance this onto a nail or in.
2.2. Under the eye-ball method, please see attachment: ILLUSTRATION B; so long as the missing area (IN YELLOW) is roughly equal to the area of theextra spacewhich I called protrusion (not exactly a protrusion, here)ifcan refer to the attachment in GREEN.Using eye-ball method this green area is roughly the area of the yellow missing area.

Quote

On 11/6/2010 7:00:10 AM, Anonymous wrote:
Since within the living area,
there is an open courtyard =
lanai
If academically speaking, this
missing area should be
considered against the
courtyard. Then based on the
concept of center of gravity;
layout A closely match this
concept: where roughly the
missing corner matches the
additional space or the
additional non living space or
protusion area may be reduced
slightly where the area of the
lanai (courtyard) equals the
other protrusion. Currently i
am only eyeballing it only.
On 11/5/2010 7:35:33 PM, Anonymous
wrote:
Master Cecil,Please see the revised
attachments. By the way, there is no
garage door since the house is within a
compound. Thank you.On 11/4/2010
10:36:20 PM, Cecil Lee wrote:
It is
best to you split it into two
files
that of layout A and another for
B.
As currently, it cannot be shown.On
11/4/2010 10:35:18 PM, Anonymous
wrote:
Master Cecil,Kindly
advise
which
is the correct
centerpoint -
Layout A
or Layout B?In Layout A,

I included the garden
area
which is within the
perimeter wall
of the house.
WithLayout A,
the
centerpoint will be the

bathtub area. Ifthis is

the correct centerpoint,
should
I move the bathtub?
Thehouse
is
stillbeing

constructed.Main door

faceswest3.I

did not include
thegarage
to get the
flying stars.MS 6,
WS 1,
BS8.Thank you.

[myfs_145115]

Master Cecil,
Many thanks for the illustration. Given that the centerpoint is in the bathroom (bathtub) area, is this inauspicious? Should I make the bathroom smaller so that the centerpoint will fall outside the bathroom?
The house faces W3. MS 6, WS 1 and BS 8.
Again, many thanks.

Quote

On 11/6/2010 10:13:30 AM, Anonymous wrote:
These are futher illustrations:-1.
Frankly, even between your layout a and
b; the center-point is pretty close to
each other. Only thing is that under
layout plan a, it falls within the
toilet area (long bath)2. Under the so
called: center-of-gravity method:2.1.
The usual suggestion is to copy a layout
plan. Paste it on a cardboard and
cut-out the outline of the interior
"living" space. And balance this onto a
nail or in.2.2. Under the eye-ball
method, please see attachment:
ILLUSTRATION B; so long as the missing
area (IN YELLOW) is roughly equal to the
area of theextra spacewhich
I called protrusion (not exactly a
protrusion, here)ifcan refer
to the attachment in GREEN.Using
eye-ball method this green area is
roughly the area of the yellow missing
area. On 11/6/2010 7:00:10 AM,
Cecil Lee wrote:
Since within the
living area,
there is an open
courtyard =
lanai
If
academically speaking, this
missing
area should be
considered against
the
courtyard. Then based on the
concept of center of gravity;
layout A closely match this
concept: where roughly the
missing corner matches the
additional space or the
additional non living space or
protusion area may be reduced
slightly where the area of the
lanai (courtyard) equals the
other protrusion. Currently i
am
only eyeballing it only.
On
11/5/2010 7:35:33 PM, Anonymous
wrote:
Master Cecil,Please
see the revised
attachments. By
the way, there is no
garage door
since the house is within a
compound. Thank you.On 11/4/2010
10:36:20 PM, Cecil Lee wrote:
It is
best to you split it
into two
files
that of
layout A and another for
B.
As currently, it cannot be
shown.On
11/4/2010 10:35:18
PM, Anonymous
wrote:
Master Cecil,Kindly
advise
which
is the
correct
centerpoint -
Layout A
or Layout B?In
Layout A,

I
included the garden
area
which is within the

perimeter wall
of the
house.
WithLayout A,
the
centerpoint will be
the

bathtub area.
Ifthis is

the
correct centerpoint,
should
I move the bathtub?

Thehouse
is

stillbeing

constructed.Main door

faceswest3.&
nbsp;I

did not include

thegarage
to get
the
flying stars.MS 6,
WS 1,
BS8.Thank
you.

[Cecil Lee]

These are some considerations:-
1. You stay there, I (geomancer) don't!
1.1. Thus it would be very irresponsible for me to give you a one line advice! And you may have to live with such a consequence.
2. Just imagine a bomb. Even a bomb or a grenade when it detonates; has a critical radius. Thus, don't just think that just because the centre of gravity is only a pin prick, it is only at that dot.
3. Just look at the illustration b, I provided. The area is at least larger than the red circle I drawn around the "pin prick" centre of gravity.
4. Thus, what makes one think that by say shrinking the toilet (a little) one's worry is totally erased.
5. As mentioned, many times; toilet at the centrepoint is considered as one leak. And in your case, not that bad given that it is not the wc (toilet bowl).
6. Usually if there are problems; problems occur when a home has three or more MAJOR leaks.

Quote

On 11/6/2010 2:02:31 PM, Anonymous wrote:
Master Cecil,Many thanks for the
illustration. Given that the centerpoint
is in the bathroom (bathtub) area, is
this inauspicious? Should I make the
bathroom smaller so that the centerpoint
will fall outside the bathroom? The
house faces W3. MS 6, WS 1 and BS
8.Again, many thanks.On 11/6/2010
10:13:30 AM, Cecil Lee wrote:
These
are futher illustrations:-1.
Frankly, even between your layout a
and
b; the center-point is pretty
close to
each other. Only thing is
that under
layout plan a, it falls
within the
toilet area (long bath)2.
Under the so
called:
center-of-gravity method:2.1.
The
usual suggestion is to copy a layout
plan. Paste it on a cardboard and
cut-out the outline of the interior
"living" space. And balance this
onto a
nail or in.2.2. Under the
eye-ball
method, please see
attachment:
ILLUSTRATION B; so long
as the missing
area (IN YELLOW) is
roughly equal to the
area of
theextra spacewhich
I
called protrusion (not exactly a
protrusion, here)ifcan
refer
to the attachment in
GREEN.Using
eye-ball method
this green area is
roughly the
area of the yellow missing
area.
On 11/6/2010 7:00:10 AM,
Cecil
Lee wrote:
Since within the
living area,
there is an open
courtyard =
lanai
If
academically speaking, this
missing
area should be
considered against
the
courtyard. Then based on the
concept of center of gravity;
layout A closely match this
concept: where roughly the
missing corner matches the
additional space or the
additional non living space or
protusion area may be reduced
slightly where the area of the
lanai (courtyard) equals the
other protrusion. Currently i
am
only eyeballing it only.
On
11/5/2010 7:35:33 PM,
Anonymous
wrote:
Master
Cecil,Please
see the revised
attachments. By
the way,
there is no
garage door
since the house is within a

compound. Thank you.On
11/4/2010
10:36:20 PM, Cecil
Lee wrote:
It is
best to
you split it
into two
files
that of
layout A and another
for
B.
As currently, it
cannot be
shown.On

11/4/2010 10:35:18
PM,
Anonymous
wrote:

Master Cecil,Kindly

advise
which
is the
correct
centerpoint
-
Layout A
or
Layout B?In
Layout A,

I
included the
garden
area
which is
within the

perimeter
wall
of the
house.

WithLayout A,
the
centerpoint will
be
the

bathtub area.
Ifthis is

the
correct centerpoint,

should
I move the
bathtub?

Thehouse
is

stillbeing

constructed.Main
door

faceswest
;3.&
nbsp;I

did
not include

thegarage
to
get
the
flying
stars.MS 6,
WS 1,

BS8.Thank
you.

[Cecil Lee]

Do take note that it is not just about the centerpoint (centrepoint) or the center-of-gravity.
Please see attachment: and where is the area occupied by the CENTER SQUARE or GRID.

[myfs_145115]

Master Cecil,
Thank you for easing my mind that this is not a major leak. But is this still considered a minor leak?
Many thanks.

Quote

On 11/6/2010 3:14:19 PM, Anonymous wrote:
Do take note that it is not
just about the centerpoint
(centrepoint) or the
center-of-gravity.Please see
attachment: and where is the
area occupied by the CENTER
SQUARE or GRID.

[Cecil Lee]

I reproduce my comments, below:-
=== START ===
These are some considerations:-
1. You stay there, I (geomancer) don't!
1.1. Thus it would be very irresponsible for me to give you a one line advice! And you may have to live with such a consequence.
2. Just imagine a bomb. Even a bomb or a grenade when it detonates; has a critical radius. Thus, don't just think that just because the centre of gravity is only a pin prick, it is only at that dot.
3. Just look at the illustration b, I provided. The area is at least larger than the red circle I drawn around the "pin prick" centre of gravity.
4. Thus, what makes one think that by say shrinking the toilet (a little) one's worry is totally erased.
5. As mentioned, many times; toilet at the centrepoint is considered as one leak. And in your case, not that bad given that it is not the wc (toilet bowl).
6. Usually if there are problems; problems occur when a home has three or more MAJOR leaks.
=== END ===
Please re-read, above. Where did I ever mention any terms like MINOR or MAJOR leaks other than the last statement under Para 6?
Under Para5, I just mentioned that it is just one leak.And I did not mentionthat it is a minor or major leak.Please note that it can still be a major leak even if the toilet bowl is not at the "pin prick" area.
Furthermore,in the last illustration, I did show that the centre-grid or square is pretty large and again not just a "pin prick". In addition, please re-read Para 2, above.
I hope it is not a case of HOPE and Denial type of situation. "Oh he says no major leak - and Iam very happy with this statement."BUT show me, wheredid I ever say it is firstly not a MAJOR leak....???

Quote

On 11/7/2010 9:22:11 PM, Anonymous wrote:
Master Cecil,Thank you for easing my
mind that this is not a major leak. But
is this still considered a minor
leak?Many thanks.On 11/6/2010 3:14:19
PM, Cecil Lee wrote:
Do take note
that it is not
just about the
centerpoint
(centrepoint) or the
center-of-gravity.Please see
attachment: and where is the
area occupied by the CENTER
SQUARE or GRID.