Who are mistaken?

[neym]

Who are mistaken?
In accordance with some books my element is WATER according to my date of birth.
Because the gratuitous report indicates me the following:
This personalized report is prepared for Ney Gonz?lez
S?nchez:-
Gender: Male
Date of Birth: 25 Jan 1963 between 9.00 a.m. to 10.59 a.m.
Chinese Lunar Date of Birth:-
Your Chinese Date of Birth is 1963, 1st month, 1 day, between 9.00 a.m. to
10.59 a.m .
Pre-Analyse Birth Element
You are considered a Earth, therefore you are regarded overall as a "yang Earth
person".
Could somebody help me to understand better this contradiction?

[Robert Lee]

Dear Ney Gonz?lez S?nchez,
Please read below:-

Quote

On 9/12/99 3:57:37 AM, Anonymous wrote:
Who are mistaken?
In accordance with some books
my element is WATER according
to my date of birth.

This is because they take your element based on the year of birth. For example:-
25 Jan 1963 between 9.00 a.m. to 10.59 a.m.
This is the 1st day in 1963.
1963 is represented by gui-mao, which is yin Water - yin Wood.
Some authors like to take the heavenly stem representation which is yin Water, while others like to take the earthly branch yin Wood.
In which either case are both correct depending on its uses.
Thus, you were termed as water, based on the heavenly stem version of it. This is the quick Pillars version of determining your element.
If you were taken as wood, it is based on the astrological influence of the year which is also correct.
However, please note that, if you take this as your birth element, it would also mean that millions of people around the world who are born in the chinese year of 1963 then all are water and wood. This is very inaccurate and does not personalise it.

Quote

Because the gratuitous report
indicates me the following:
This personalized report is
prepared for Ney Gonz?lez
S?nchez:-
Gender: Male
Date of Birth: 25 Jan 1963
between 9.00 a.m. to 10.59
a.m.
Chinese Lunar Date of Birth:-
Your Chinese Date of Birth is
1963, 1st month, 1 day,
between 9.00 a.m. to
10.59 a.m .
Pre-Analyse Birth Element
You are considered a Earth,
therefore you are regarded
overall as a "yang Earth
person".

This is your true element based on the Pillars generate by geomancy-online. This has taken into account the changing influence of each day, as for a particular year, there can be a day which is represented by a different element.
Thus, providing you with the most accurate element of your birth. Under this pillars, everyone in the same year will have a range of different elements depending upon which day and month which he or she is born.
The free report does not provide you with the true element strength's but it does provide you the correct birth element.
Hope that helps to clarify your answer.
Warmest Regards
Robert Lee

Quote

Could somebody help me to
understand better this
contradiction?